For peanut butter lovers, this one’s for you. Mr. Tod’s 10" Reese’s Cream Pie features layers of peanut butter cream, crushed chocolate cookies, and a smooth chocolate topping. All nestled inside a flaky crust that brings texture and richness to every slice.
Handcrafted with the same care as our signature pies, it’s a bold, indulgent twist on a classic Southern dessert.
Best served chilled. Pairs perfectly with cold milk or hot coffee.
ONLY AVAILABLE FOR LOCAL DELIVERY. CANNOT BE SHIPPED. 2 PIE MINIMUM FOR LOCAL DELIVERY IN NORTHERN/CENTRAL NJ. Manufactured in a facility that contains nuts.
- Prefer local delivery? Find us on DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub!