Mr. Tod's 10" Sweet Potato Pie - Authentic Southern Recipe

$49.99

(19 reviews) Write a Review

SKU:: SP10

There’s a reason this pie made us famous. Mr. Tod’s 10" Sweet Potato Pie is the ultimate Southern comfort — smooth, rich, and kissed with warm spices. Handcrafted in small batches, it starts with fresh sweet potatoes, European-style butter, and real vanilla extract.

Baked into a golden, flaky crust, this pie delivers nostalgia in every bite — the kind of dessert that brings families together. Whether you're hosting for the holidays or treating yourself, it’s a timeless favorite worth savoring.

Serve warm with whipped cream or enjoy chilled. Ships fresh and ready to enjoy.

Prefer local delivery? Find us on DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub!

Current Stock:

Quantity:

There’s a reason this pie made us famous. Mr. Tod’s 10" Sweet Potato Pie is the ultimate Southern comfort — smooth, rich, and kissed with warm spices. Handcrafted in small batches, it starts with fresh sweet potatoes, European-style butter, and real vanilla extract.

Baked into a golden, flaky crust, this pie delivers nostalgia in every bite — the kind of dessert that brings families together. Whether you're hosting for the holidays or treating yourself, it’s a timeless favorite worth savoring.

Serve warm with whipped cream or enjoy chilled. Ships fresh and ready to enjoy.

Prefer local delivery? Find us on DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub!

19 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

5
Sweet potato pies

Posted by Renee Sheffey on Dec 28th 2024

This is as close to grandma’s pies as you’re going to get! I had an issue with my order and who shows up to my home on CHRISTMAS morning? Mr. Tod himself!! Please support this business! Quality pies and excellent customer service. Five stars!
5
Sweet potato pie

Posted by Kathreen Brice on Jan 5th 2024

Just simply delicious and delectable.
5
Great Gift

Posted by Emma on Mar 5th 2021

I have yet to actually try the pie, but I sent a couple as gifts! They recipients were very happy! Shipped out right away! Great customer service.
5
Tastes like mom's!

Posted by Ida Johnson on Dec 23rd 2020

This pie is the closest thing I've had to my mother's. Once she passed I thought I'd forever miss ot, but thanks to Mr. Tod's, I don't have to!
5
Sweet potato pie

Posted by Nick Shenkler on Dec 2nd 2020

Have you ever seen the eyes of god? If your answer is no, then you obviously haven’t taken a bite out of this pie.
4
Sweet Potato Pie

Posted by Ellen Marie Sundstrom on Dec 1st 2020

Filling amazing, bottom crust was great, crimped crust rather tough to consume, excellent packing for shipping - all in all worth the price and shipping cost to eat a dessert reminiscent of the time I lived in Florida
5
Sweet Potato Pie

Posted by Michael on Nov 30th 2020

Great tasting pie. I will most certainly buy again.
5
Sweet Potato Pie

Posted by Kathreen Brice on Nov 25th 2020

Delicious as always
5
I only buy pies from here

Posted by Natalia Han on Aug 24th 2020

rich flavor, love the cinnamon, great texture, quick delivery, amazing customer service